Eh. When you start talking about “society”, you’re implicitly talking about a thing real humans run. A whole lot of ideas have been tried, over the centuries; the power structures that are still around are a good sample of the ones that were actually able to last.
I think anytime we’re talking about decisions that were made hundreds, or in this case even thousands of years ago, it is safe to assume that they are suboptimal, to say the very least. I mean, you could trace a lot of important aspects of society back to eras of profound ignorance. We’re talking about glorified cavemen. They were not even capable of asking the right questions, let alone answering them, let alone acting effectively on those answers. (We’re not today, either, tbh, but we’ve made significant intellectual progress, at least.)
“Able to last” through such eras is not a ringing endorsement. It doesn’t mean any particular social construct was the best back then, let alone now. What it means is that it was easy enough to enforce, in eras when science didn’t exist, when nobody understood germ theory, when people were executed because they claimed that Earth revolved the sun or that “zero” was a thing.
There’s been so little real experimentation in the grand scheme of things. That doesn’t mean the status quo is good. It means the inertia of entire society is extremely strong, and many cultures have made the same mistakes in many eras.
You’re talking about it like nothing has happened over that whole period, and we’re still doing corvee for the pharaoh. No, history is big. Things have been tried, and not worked as intended, and then been tried again anyway in a completely different place and time.
A system being able to last definitely doesn’t mean good, but it is a bare minimum. A set of rules everyone ignores isn’t a society at all.
There’s been so little real experimentation in the grand scheme of things.
Well, if you have an example, and it holds, that will change this entire discussion. Like, I could just say “no, there’s been a lot”, but we might as well get right to something specific.
Usually, when someone sits down to write a manifesto, they come up with a mix of a bunch of ideas that are actually pretty old. Granted, something has been very different for the last 200 years or so, but one still needs to justify why we should bring back, like, ancient Greek sortition (for example).
Eh. When you start talking about “society”, you’re implicitly talking about a thing real humans run. A whole lot of ideas have been tried, over the centuries; the power structures that are still around are a good sample of the ones that were actually able to last.
Economies, there’s more latitude to talk about.
I think anytime we’re talking about decisions that were made hundreds, or in this case even thousands of years ago, it is safe to assume that they are suboptimal, to say the very least. I mean, you could trace a lot of important aspects of society back to eras of profound ignorance. We’re talking about glorified cavemen. They were not even capable of asking the right questions, let alone answering them, let alone acting effectively on those answers. (We’re not today, either, tbh, but we’ve made significant intellectual progress, at least.)
“Able to last” through such eras is not a ringing endorsement. It doesn’t mean any particular social construct was the best back then, let alone now. What it means is that it was easy enough to enforce, in eras when science didn’t exist, when nobody understood germ theory, when people were executed because they claimed that Earth revolved the sun or that “zero” was a thing.
There’s been so little real experimentation in the grand scheme of things. That doesn’t mean the status quo is good. It means the inertia of entire society is extremely strong, and many cultures have made the same mistakes in many eras.
You’re talking about it like nothing has happened over that whole period, and we’re still doing corvee for the pharaoh. No, history is big. Things have been tried, and not worked as intended, and then been tried again anyway in a completely different place and time.
A system being able to last definitely doesn’t mean good, but it is a bare minimum. A set of rules everyone ignores isn’t a society at all.
Well, if you have an example, and it holds, that will change this entire discussion. Like, I could just say “no, there’s been a lot”, but we might as well get right to something specific.
Usually, when someone sits down to write a manifesto, they come up with a mix of a bunch of ideas that are actually pretty old. Granted, something has been very different for the last 200 years or so, but one still needs to justify why we should bring back, like, ancient Greek sortition (for example).