You’re not taking the tankie argument to the end. If all states are authoritarian, are they all equivalent? And the answer is no, they differ in class character. It’s not the authority of a state above class society oppressing all, it’s the authority of a class oppressing the other classes in society. Democracy for the ruling class, dictatorship for the oppressed classes. Socialism is the first form of state where the ruling class is the majority of society, the working class.
Then we get into how we get rid of the state, and the answer points to ending class, because the state is a product of class struggle. This means we need to collectivize all production and distribution globally, and the only class interested in doing so is the proletariat, which is why the proletariat must be in charge of the state.
Hahahaha now neoliberals are tankies? Holy shit you guys are demented
That’s why they’re called “tankies”.
Also, no its not. Its not based on some vague concept of belief. It was a trotskyite derogatory used against MLs who were supportive of the USSR intervention in Hungary in 1952. This intervention had tanks rolling into Hungary, hence the word “tankie”. Interestingly a few years ago we got confirmation from CIAs own archives that the Hungarian revolution (mainly led by Nazis) was indeed a colour revolution funded by the CIA - So without “tankies” Hungary would have fallen under a coup government of ex-nazis. I wonder how things would fare in your utopia when a colour revolution is attempted and all opposition to it is decried to be “authoritarian”?
Over time the word “tankie” got co-opted by liberals (as leftist terminology always does, the latest of which is accelerationism and campism, other bangers include “imperiaism”) and reduced down to mean “anyone to the left of me.”
So, again, “tankie” isn’t due to some vague concept of supporting any type of “authoritarianism” since that would then just describe everybody, but instead a descriptor for a specific group of MLs.
By your definition Buenaventura Durruti would be a tankie.
The tankie arguments in favor of authoritarianism are truly a gift of word salad.
Yep, exactly. That’s what you’re promoting.
Yep, you’re promoting capitalism as well.
Yes, authoritarianism is based on violent control. That’s why they’re called “tankies”.
You’re not taking the tankie argument to the end. If all states are authoritarian, are they all equivalent? And the answer is no, they differ in class character. It’s not the authority of a state above class society oppressing all, it’s the authority of a class oppressing the other classes in society. Democracy for the ruling class, dictatorship for the oppressed classes. Socialism is the first form of state where the ruling class is the majority of society, the working class.
Then we get into how we get rid of the state, and the answer points to ending class, because the state is a product of class struggle. This means we need to collectivize all production and distribution globally, and the only class interested in doing so is the proletariat, which is why the proletariat must be in charge of the state.
Hahahaha now neoliberals are tankies? Holy shit you guys are demented
Also, no its not. Its not based on some vague concept of belief. It was a trotskyite derogatory used against MLs who were supportive of the USSR intervention in Hungary in 1952. This intervention had tanks rolling into Hungary, hence the word “tankie”. Interestingly a few years ago we got confirmation from CIAs own archives that the Hungarian revolution (mainly led by Nazis) was indeed a colour revolution funded by the CIA - So without “tankies” Hungary would have fallen under a coup government of ex-nazis. I wonder how things would fare in your utopia when a colour revolution is attempted and all opposition to it is decried to be “authoritarian”?
Over time the word “tankie” got co-opted by liberals (as leftist terminology always does, the latest of which is accelerationism and campism, other bangers include “imperiaism”) and reduced down to mean “anyone to the left of me.”
So, again, “tankie” isn’t due to some vague concept of supporting any type of “authoritarianism” since that would then just describe everybody, but instead a descriptor for a specific group of MLs.
By your definition Buenaventura Durruti would be a tankie.
So, how is the Global South supposed to resist colonialism without violence?